Cash-Out Refinance vs. Home Equity Loan: Which is Better?
Both options let you tap your home equity, but they work very differently. Here's which one saves you more money.
How They Work
A cash-out refinance replaces your existing mortgage with a larger one and gives you the difference in cash. A home equity loan is a second mortgage — a separate loan on top of your existing mortgage.
Both use your home as collateral and both allow you to access equity, but the structure is fundamentally different.
Cash-Out Refinance Pros and Cons
Advantages:
Disadvantages: Higher closing costs (2-5% of total loan), resets your amortization schedule, you lose your current rate if it was lower.
- Single monthly payment
- Often lower interest rate than a home equity loan
- Can potentially lower your existing rate at the same time
- Fixed rate options available
- Closing costs can be rolled into the loan
Home Equity Loan Pros and Cons
Advantages:
Disadvantages: Second monthly payment, generally higher interest rate than a cash-out refi, your existing mortgage terms remain unchanged.
- Keep your existing low-rate first mortgage
- Lower closing costs
- Fixed rate and fixed payment
- Typically faster to close
The Decision Framework
Choose cash-out refinance if your current rate is higher than today's rates (you save twice). Choose a home equity loan if your current rate is lower than today's rates (don't sacrifice a great rate). If rates are similar, compare the total cost of each option over 5-10 years.

